Badges- what would you change?

This is something myself and others on my sqn talk about a fair bit, so I want to know what everyone else thinks. If you could create a new badge, what would it be for? How would it be done? If you were change anything about any badge, what would it be? The syllabus? How its taught?
Nothing personal, just asking out of curiosity :slight_smile:

I’d modify the current PTS syllabi to require a more even level of accomplishment across the board - ie giving out a badge for heartstart is ludicrous IMO.

Blue badge - 8h teaching, practical assessment
Bronze badge - 16h teaching, practical and theoretical assessments
Silver badge - 1 week residential course, or two weekends plus additional learning. At least 3 assessments, at least one each written/practical
Gold - equivalent of two full weeks, at least one week continuous - four assessments, at least one each written/practical

1 Like

That does seem to make rather good sense. But if we were to talk about cyber for example. Obviously there isn’t a blue badge, to gain the ‘blue cyber’ qualification, it is literally just watching a video. Bronze cyber IMO wouldn’t need 16 hours, only based on the fact that the current course (not sure what it will be like after amendments) does not take that long to teach, however I do definitely think some form assessment should be implemented. As for silver, I do feel that the self taught syllabus is ridiculous as a lot of people may gain the qualification but have little to no interest in cyber and the information given would be no use to them whatsoever. My apologies for using Cyber as an example, mainly due to the fact that I think, personally, that it should be changed, a lot.

Not at all - and that follows my point.

By the sounds of it all of the cyber should be moved down a level.

1 Like

Looks fine in theory, but what is it in reality a bit of cloth to go on a uniform. You can pimp it all you like but that’s what it is when all said and done. Greater than 99% of cadets wouldn’t think about it or refer to it.

What is the timeframe for this idea? Given it seems the average 2½ year life expectancy of a cadet.

The weekends require staffing and in our Wing apart from those within the cliques, no one gets involved. It has seen a reduction in people helping unless they need a tick for their matrices.
You also need cadets and they can get too much in the way of courses and parents make the final call on their attendance.

The main thing I would change about the badges is that we should actually have them available through the system, free to the units, when they are needed and earned.

I’d look at which major activities we carry out which do not currently have a badge associated with it and add badges - sports and drill spring to mind. I would also make the radio/cyber badges share a single badge position and I’d fix the shooting badges so that colour represents skill just like every other badge.

The underlying PTS needs modification and proper management to ensure that the effort required at each level is comparable with other subjects: A few hours of DPP, practice and an assessment (radio) is not equivalent to sitting through a video for 2 hours and having a quick go (heartstart).

4 Likes

I’d solve the badge supply problem by scrapping all these damned badges.

Progressive training with levels of assessment - yes. I’m a big supporter.
A badge to celebrate each level, no matter how utterly basic - hell no!

6 Likes

Yup, that was essentially my point.

Very little would actually change based upon my scheme, other than what badges actually get awarded for what course.

I’m evermore sceptical that you actually have any interactions with any cadets these days…

4 Likes

He doesn’t. He’s said on previous posts that as OC he wouldn’t accept a request to talk from a cadet, they need to go to the squadron SNCO

1 Like

to be fair there are sports badges - Wing Blues. however these have no place on the uniform.
i have heard several times in my several years that the Wing blue should have a location on uniform…

I know, but they aren’t appropriate for use on a brassard, hence the suggestion. I probably should have specified “a brassard badge associated with it”

@Giminion They may get “excited” at the time but a couple of months after and then on leaving the Corps, it won’t figure in their lives.
What has to become front and centre for anything like this is the impact on cadet and staff free time. On paper it’s easy to say x weekends for this or that, but those weekends are people’s free time. OK if you are single and or have no home life, or like a few staff I know only have the ATC and their whole life revolves around it, but for the normal ones out here we have other things to do. I give my time for the things I enjoy as I don’t feel I have to run around like a puppy. Not gone unnoticed as people say they don’t see me around as much and when I explain, I get an OK. I’ve done my bit with chasing around, so now it’s the young bloods’ chance.

@Farmerdan Never heard of the CoC? As a cadet it was speak to the cadet SNCO, then the SWO and then and only then if after the SWO had spoken to the OC and spoken to you, did you get to speak to the OC.

I have heard of the chain of command, but I also understand the importance of the OC not being a stand offish, arrogant, stuck up individual who refuses to engage with the kids unless forced to. As a cadet I had a fantastic OC who led a staff team of 12 ( those were the days!) but who was always involved and spoke to the kids.
I also find it funny you mention the chain of command here when it means you don’t need to get involved but denigrate the whole military system or any form of hierarchy elsewhere

5 Likes

We know from the safeguarding thread that he’s not very up on these things. Why, do we all suppose, would a cadet would be wanting to circumvent the CoC?

So you’re complaining about stuff that doesn’t affect you because you take the option available as a volunteer to prioritise other things, while you admit that those it does affect are better able to be affected and also exercise their right to choose?

You’ve been doing a lot of mental gymnastics recently.

3/10, must troll harder.

1 Like

I’d move the goal posts…some of these blue badges seem to be an attendance badge

5 Likes

Ive fixed that for you

That’s not fair - blue radio definitely isn’t (if done correctly), along with leadership and pre-DofE.

1 Like

I’ll second this. I definitely fail more blue leadership task attempts than I pass!

1 Like