Who are not issued 1s at public expense
I don’t think this is a fair comparison, the role of a CFAV (and an officer in particular) is wildly different to that of a senior cadet. It’s apples to oranges.
Who are not issued 1s at public expense
I don’t think this is a fair comparison, the role of a CFAV (and an officer in particular) is wildly different to that of a senior cadet. It’s apples to oranges.
My personal stance right, this is my PERSONAl stance not my WO RAFAC position on the matter, because we have a committee of people to advise on matters like this.
If I was asked pick between issuing No 1s or Issue cadets with new PCS, boots and shoes and all badges so it’s not private purchase .
I’m picking the later. These days it’s all about return on investment and id rather cadets didn’t have to spend money on stuff they wear nightly instead of a couple of times a year for a year to 18months
![]()
Which is the argument made for the ACF and CCF (A) as to why we don’t have other forms of issued uniform. I would love for our Cadets to have issued boots, but I also understand the unique challenges with that.
I would chin off number ones, not just scaling but entitlement to wear. Otherwise (as now for NCOs) there’s pressure to private purchase.
Keep them for OC Wings and RWOs/WWOs perhaps.
While I completely agree and it’s what I would do if writing ACP1358 from scratch… I shudder to imagine the absolute riot from the people who have paid for them/paid for tailoring/reranking if the rules changed to say no
If you keep them for oc wings them Better to keep as it for all officers as otherwise you just have people avoiding promotion due to cost unless they are independently wealthy.
Mess dress cost £1400. No 1 around £1100. Fg Off VA is about £100 per day.
so mess dress is 15 days VA, no 1s 11 days VA.
My thinking would be to scale OCW/WWO.
But remove for rest.
I certainly know of a fair few officers who’ve left after just a couple of years, and how many times will they have worn their No2s?
I believe the cost of no 1 for officers who leave in their first five years is recoupable (one way to aid retention).
Alternatively, I think we should commission people once they’ve been in a while and performed certain roles.
That’d stop a lot of people joining and commissioning, then realising it’s not for them and leaving within a short period of time.
If it were me, I’d get rid of the cadet direct entry SNCO/Officer routes, everyone’s a CI for a bit.
Perhaps keep the SNCO route, but at least keep commission gates behind a bit of “being a CFAV” first
Thread drift, but I’d bring them in as Air Recruits with zero expectation except safeguarding.
Then get them through the main course and out as AS2s. Then AS1s after some experience.
Makes uniformed service more accessible to those without military experience, and then SNCO status as a sgt becomes something genuinely earned and indicating significant experience.
It’s good enough for reservists, regardless of how senior or academically qualified they are.
Whilst this has its merits, it would need 3 service and CCF to support, and I don’t see that happening,
However, in our wing at least everyone had to start as a CI until the latest over 18s changes. I think it was even stipulated on the ACO website, as was.
And the application process for a commission took a lot longer too.
Back to topic; I see no reason for CWOs to have No1s and really given the cost pressures reducing the scaling of No1s more widely seems a sensible move.
I appear to be lost, can someone help me please?
I’m looking for the topic?
You might not be scaled for it.
Bit like cadet WO & No 1s….
All the arguments against No. 1s sound very reasonable, until you go to a Remembrance Parade or high profile event and all the SCC and RMC are in No. 1s or Lovats.
My solution to all the issues with the costs of tailoring, re-ranking, etc. would be a proper No. 2 jacket, in lieu of the awful GPJ, that has medal ribbons, flying / profession badges, etc.
RMC locally are in 1s not even lovats! But at the other end of the scale, the ACF are in MTP!
Thunderbird!!!
Since being issued mine 7/8 years ago they have been worn about 7/8 times in total - averaging once per year.
They effectively come out for remembrance parade and maybe an awards ceremony if I’m invited.
SNCOs have never been scaled for No.1s and therefore is private purchase. As an officer I received an initial issue - re ranking along recently was a 3 figure bill, plus the travel to the tailor during the working week etc. A lot of money for something barely worn.
I think the expectation is still for Officers to be in No1s at appropriate occasions - as they have been issued a set.
Honestly, I wouldn’t. In my world I would have removed No1s from being issued years ago, and used the significant saving (£1000+ per set) to invest in issuing our CFAVs No3s - a much more widely used uniform that directly facilitates training value.
The ACF were all in MTP, including the staff - there is also an argument that within the body of troops all should be in the same uniform - which would need to be No.2 Full.
If you want everyone the same, it would have to be MTP (like in joint units, but even we get our sS dress out for ceremonial occasions).
But every now and again they have a CSM/RSM in their equivalent of our No1, and a Coy officer and/or service instructor wearing it too, at least where we are.
Ah, no you miss understand me.
The parade is made up of multiple formations.
RBL
ACF
ATC
Each of these formations should be in the same uniform, so for the ATC this would be No.2.
This year, I joined with my local Sqn, bring the total of uniformed CFAVs on parade to 5, 4 of us where in No.1 (only because 2 super keen Sgts have privately purchased and clearly have spare dosh knocking around) the remaining member of staff was dressed the same as cadets - with peak rather than beret.
Should the formation be mixed?
If you had a regular unit actually parading, they would all be issued 1’s from the loan pool for that activity right…